top of page

Cooking with oils and animal fats: what the science actually says

Oct 16
4 min read

Updated: Oct 19

We hear so many different opinions about what are healthy cooking habits, that I couldn't see the wood for the trees anymore. I did some digging and found the following: hope it helps you too, because choosing a cooking fat feels like it should be simple: and then you start reading labels, headlines, and all the competing claims. Seed oils are either “toxic” or “heart-protective.” Animal fats are either “ancestral wisdom” or “LDL elevators.” The truth, as usual, sits somewhere in the middle. It really comes down to three practical things:

  • How the fat holds up when we heat it

  • What it does to our blood lipids

  • How those effects play out over years of eating


What makes a cooking fat “good”

A good cooking fat has to pull off two jobs at once:

  1. Stay chemically stable at the temperatures you actually cook with

  2. Support (not sabotage) our long-term heart health once it ends up in our food and in our diet


Stability mostly comes down to the fat’s fatty-acid structure:

  • Saturated fats -> no double bonds, so they resist oxidation really well

  • Monounsaturated fats -> one double bond, moderately stable

  • Polyunsaturated fats -> multiple double bonds, break down more easily and can create polar compounds and aldehydes that end up in your food

    (for a more detailed explanation, read my blog: saturated and unsaturated fatty acids)


Smoke point (the temperature where you see visible smoke) is a late and imperfect warning sign. Real degradation often starts earlier. Natural antioxidants like polyphenols and tocopherols give some oils extra protection, which is why certain less-refined oils can actually outperform higher-smoke-point refined ones in controlled heating tests.


On the health side, the consistent finding from randomized trials and big cohort studies is pretty clear:

  • Swapping saturated fat for unsaturated fat lowers our LDL cholesterol (a causal driver of atherosclerosis)

  • Higher intake of plant fats, especially from vegetable oils, is linked to lower overall and cardiovascular mortality

  • Higher animal-fat intake tracks in the opposite direction



Animal fats: the case for and against

Butter, ghee, lard (pig), and beef tallow are high in saturated fat (usually 50 % or more), with a solid amount of monounsaturated fat and almost no polyunsaturated fat.


The upsides

  • Excellent heat stability

  • Ghee and tallow handle high temperatures cleanly

  • Butter’s milk solids lower its practical smoke point, so clarified versions work better

  • Great flavour and texture that a lot of cooks love

  • Modest amounts of fat-soluble vitamins


The downsides

  • Multiple randomised trials show these fats raise LDL cholesterol compared with unsaturated plant oils

  • Network meta-analyses put butter near the bottom of the list for blood lipids

  • Prospective data link higher animal-fat consumption with higher cardiovascular and total mortality risk

Bottom line: Using them occasionally for flavour or specific high-heat techniques is totally reasonable. Making them your everyday default fat isn’t backed by the weight of the evidence.


Plant oils: strengths, limits, and rankings

Extra-virgin olive oil is still the strongest all-rounder:

  • Mostly monounsaturated (about 70–75 % oleic acid = omega 9)

  • Relatively low in polyunsaturated fat

  • Packed with polyphenols

  • The PREDIMED trial and later reviews link higher intake to fewer cardiovascular events, better lipid profiles, and lower mortality

  • Heating studies show it produces fewer polar compounds than many refined seed oils that list higher smoke points, thanks to its fatty-acid profile and antioxidants

  • Handles everyday sautéing, roasting, and pan-frying just fine


Avocado oil

  • Similar monounsaturated profile

  • Higher smoke point when refined, so it’s practical for searing or hotter cooking


High-oleic versions of sunflower (USA), safflower, or canola oil

  • Better oxidative stability than the regular high-polyunsaturated versions

  • High in linoleic acid (= omega 6 -> about 65 - 70% )

  • Still improve blood lipids compared to saturated fat


Conventional seed oils rich in linoleic acid (corn, soybean, standard sunflower, grapeseed)

  • Lower LDL when they replace saturated fat

  • Might raise inflammatory markers

  • Higher polyunsaturated content makes them more prone to oxidation under prolonged or very high heat → better suited to moderate temperatures


Coconut and palm oils

  • Heat-stable because of their saturated-fat content

  • Raise LDL more than unsaturated oils → not the best choice for everyday use


Margarines and non-pure-oil cooking liquids

  • These are emulsions of vegetable oils/fats (often soybean, canola, sunflower, palm, or blends) with water (typically ~20% for full-fat versions with ≥80% fat; lower-fat “light” versions have more water).

  • Modern versions are usually made without partial hydrogenation-> check lable for this term

  • Margarines are lower in saturated fat than butter and provide unsaturated fats (mono- and polyunsaturated, including omega-6 and sometimes omega-3 depending on the base oils), but check for the term 'hydrogenated' or related words.



Practical recommendations

  • For most of our home cooking, extra-virgin olive oil is the evidence-backed default: solid chemistry, protective compounds, and the strongest clinical support

  • Reach for refined olive oil, avocado oil, or a high-oleic alternative when temperatures regularly go above about 200–220 °C

  • Treat animal fats as specialty tools rather than everyday staples

  • High-polyunsaturated seed oils can still have a place at lower heat or as part of shifting away from saturated fat, but they’re not ideal for repeated deep-frying


In short: no single fat is perfect on its own. The temperature you’re using is leading here and keep monounsaturated-rich oils with natural antioxidants at the centre of your kitchen. This approach is both scientifically grounded and actually workable in real cooking.

Comments


bottom of page